See photos and updates from listings directly in your feed
Share your favorite listings with friends and family
Save your search and get new listings directly in your mailbox before everybody else
The decision between short-term and long-term rentals has always been a balancing act between higher income potential and stability. As we move into 2025, various economic, regulatory, and market factors continue to influence rental profitability. Whether you are a property investor or a homeowner looking to maximize returns, understanding the pros and cons of both rental strategies is crucial.
Short-Term Rentals: High Earnings with Higher Risks
Short-term rentals (STRs), often listed on platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo, offer flexibility and high income potential. Hosts can charge premium rates, especially in tourist-heavy locations, major cities, or areas with seasonal demand. The benefits of STRs include:
- Higher Nightly Rates: The biggest appeal of STRs is the ability to charge significantly more per night compared to long-term leases. This is especially lucrative in high-demand seasons or during major local events.
- Flexibility: Owners have the option to use the property for personal use whenever needed. This is ideal for those who wish to maintain a vacation home while generating income.
- Potential Tax Benefits: Some jurisdictions offer tax advantages for short-term rentals, particularly if they are rented for fewer than 14 days per year.
However, short-term rentals come with challenges, including:
- Inconsistent Occupancy Rates: While peak seasons can bring substantial earnings, off-seasons can lead to prolonged vacancies and lower income.
- Higher Operational Costs: Regular cleaning, maintenance, utilities, and restocking essentials add to expenses, reducing profit margins.
- Regulatory and Legal Restrictions: Many cities are cracking down on STRs with strict zoning laws, permits, and taxes, which can limit rental potential.
- Management Intensity: STRs require active management, including guest communication, check-ins, maintenance, and marketing, making them labor-intensive unless outsourced to a property management service.
Long-Term Rentals: Stability and Predictability
Long-term rentals (LTRs) offer more predictable income and require less hands-on management. Tenants typically sign leases for six months to a year or more, ensuring a steady cash flow. The benefits include:
- Consistent Revenue: With a lease agreement, landlords receive monthly rent, reducing the risk of vacancies.
- Lower Management Costs: Unlike STRs, there is less need for frequent cleaning, maintenance, and guest turnover.
- Fewer Regulatory Issues: Most cities have well-established regulations for long-term rentals, making them less subject to sudden legal changes.
- Lower Vacancy Rates: With longer leases, landlords avoid frequent turnover and the associated costs of finding new tenants.
Despite these advantages, long-term rentals have some downsides:
- Lower Income Potential: Monthly rent for long-term leases is typically lower compared to the aggregated income potential of STRs.
- Limited Flexibility: Once leased, landlords cannot use the property at will.
- Tenant Risks: Issues like late payments, property damage, or evictions can arise, creating financial and legal challenges.
Which Is More Profitable in 2025?
The profitability of STRs versus LTRs in 2025 depends on several factors:
- Location: Tourist-heavy cities and regions with high vacation demand favor STRs, while stable residential areas with strong job markets support LTRs.
- Market Trends: Rising travel demand post-pandemic has boosted STR profitability, but increasing regulations may limit growth.
- Interest Rates and Housing Costs: High mortgage rates may deter homebuyers, increasing rental demand and making LTRs more appealing.
- Regulatory Environment: STR-friendly locations can yield higher profits, but areas with strict regulations may make LTRs the safer choice.
Ultimately, investors should evaluate their financial goals, risk tolerance, and local market conditions to determine which rental strategy is most profitable in 2025.
